Rediscovering lost....fakes

This post is not part of the 'One record at a time' series but an occasional post that came about due to a recent development.

I've noticed an influx of rare CDs being sold on eBay recently (they pop up on Amazon too). Various sellers seem to be offering multiple copies of brand new discs, all of which are rare and highly sought after. Some of these listing are "Buy Now" for inflated prices and some are auctions. The same seller often tries both tactics if they have enough copies.

One of the unfortunate side effects of Wendy Carlos's private nature is that she has stopped issuing her music and there have been no CDs pressed since the excellent East Side Digital releases of the early 2000's. I own four or five of these discs and wished I had bought more when I had the opportunity. The relative paucity of Carlos CDs means that second hand prices tend to be a inflated and some of the rarer releases command quite high prices. Therefore, the opportunity to buy a copy of one of these albums for £10-15 at auction seems too good an opportunity to miss.

Out of curiosity I decided to buy a copy of both volumes of "Rediscovering Lost Scores" and see what turned up. I had a suspicion I would be buying a fake CD but wanted to see for myself. Buying a CD also allowed me the opportunity to hear this music and, on the outside chance the discs were genuine, I would have a real rarity. Once the package arrived I eagerly opened it only to be immediately confronted by two poorly printed sleeves that screamed, "I am counterfeit". Yes, if it looks too good to be true then, it most certainly is.

It seems some enterprising CD pressing plant has created counterfeit copies of many rare CDs and these are now circulating in the marketplace. Whilst distinguishable from the real deal, these CDs are very good fakes. Whoever made these discs has even gone to the trouble of copying the matrixes of the original discs and the booklets have been reproduced in their entirety. Having paid this much attention to detail you would have thought they would be able to reproduce the correct font for the barcode, but this is one of the telltale signs of these counterfeit discs.

Having listened to the CDs I am pleased to have heard Wendy's music and consequently I don't feel ripped off. I have paid my money and got the music I wanted. Yes the CDs are a bit sub standard in terms of production quality, but they do the job. So who has been hurt by this apparent act of piracy? Is there an issue here?

Obviously the principle complainant in this situation would have to be Wendy herself. I have no idea what is going on in Wendy's life or why she seems to have disengaged with the music business but she has left a void. None of Wendy's music is available on digital platforms and no physical media has been produced for the better part of twenty years. Therefore it is inevitable that someone will see a money making opportunity and release her music. It is fairly easy to find websites with ".ru" domain addresses that will let you download her music as mp3 files and I suspect these discs were also pressed in the same nation. Yes, music piracy is unethical and illegal, but it is inevitable if Wendy refuses to make her music available.

The second issue with this situation is that I see people paying the inflated "Buy Now" prices of £60 for these CDs. I would assume that people are only paying this price as they believe the discs to be genuine. I had an inkling of what I was getting into and don't feel too aggrieved, but if I had paid a premium price, I would not have been pleased.

So the next time you see one of Jean-Michel Jarre's "Radiophonie" series or a copy of "Medium Rare" by Foo Fighters going cheap on eBay, you can be pretty sure it isn't kosher.