One record at a time: 117. Erasure - Chorus

Here we have the 2016 re-issue and the original 1991 pressings of "Chorus".

When I heard the debut of the title track on Radio 1, things didn't seem to go well. The feedback from the listeners wasn't very positive and one caller even branded the track, "Their worst single ever!" 

When the album was released Q magazine could only bring themselves to award it 3/5 (a mystifying misjudgment that probably gives us an indication of why they went out of business). 

I think this reaction was, in part, caused by the new direction Vince had taken with the production and sound of the music. Having suddenly declared himself dissatisfied with the timing of MIDI sequencers, Vince decided to use the Roland MC-4 which employed CV/Gate technology. As a result of this decision, the album had to be created using vintage analogue synthesizers and was limited to monophonic sequences. 

Personally I love the resulting sound but it seemed to come as a shock to some. All of the ingredients for success were here: Vince and Andy's songwriting, a myriad of analogue synthesizers, skilled producer Martyn Phillips and the inimitable Dave Bascombe mixing. So despite some early naysayers, this album did prove to be a terrific success both artistically and commercially.

My favourite tracks are "Turns the Love to Anger", "Waiting for the Day" and "Breath of Life" and only "Love to Hate You" falls a bit short to my ears. "Joan" and "Home" are prime examples of songs that require repeated listening to fully appreciate them and the final track "Home" open like a beautiful flower. 5/5

One record at a time: 116. Erasure - Wild!

Here we have a copy of the original UK pressing and the 2016 re-issue of Erasure's fourth album "Wild!". 

Personally I think the title of this album is rubbish. I also think the sleeve is pretty poor. Why go to the expense of commissioning Pierre et Gilles to build sets and take beautiful photographs to just use an out of focus shot of some leaves? It doesn't make sense.

The lead single "Drama!" in 1989 was the first time I remember a remix CD single being released along with the more conventional formats - strangely, this was not something they would repeat with the other singles taken from the album. Erasure had such strong material at this stage of their career that they could casually consign tracks such as "Sweet, Sweet Baby" to b-side status; despite it offering irrefutable proof that Vince Clarke was a genius.

The album itself kicks off with a short instrumental version of "Piano Song". The Korg M1 piano may sound 'plastic' to modern ears, but at least it has character. Today, piano patches are so realistic they are all indistinguishable from each other. Personally I am a big fan of the piano sound they used and I can't imagine this song being any other way

"Blue Savannah" is one of Erasure's finest tracks as it has the perfect pop melody, accessible lyrics and pulsating electronics. Strangely I never really liked the Kraftwerk 'influenced' "Der Deutsche Mix I" included on the remix 12", but the more traditional extended mix by Mark Saunders is well worth seeking out. "How many times?" offers a nice change of pace with its laid back TR-808 beat and washes of Korg M1 presets.

I was never convinced of the merits of "Star" and releasing it as a single felt like a mistake to me. "Brother and Sister" and "2,000 Miles" seemed like much more radio friendly tracks to promote the album and they remain some of my favourites on the album. "La Gloria" is just trying too hard to be 'different' and ends up sounding trite and forced. "You Surround Me" is a good track that finds a perfect balance between electronics and Andy's soaring vocal. "Crown of Thorns" is a nonsensical folk influenced dirge that I cannot recommend, but the vocal version of "Piano Song" that follows is rather brilliant. 4/5

One record at a time: 115. Erasure - The Innocents

As with the previous Erasure album "The Circus", my pursuit of a good quality pressing has led me to own three copies of "The Innocents". I have two original pressings and the 2016 180g reissue. I seem to remember buying a second copy of the original as I thought mine didn't include the poster that was given away with the initial run. However, my memory was faulty and so I now own two copies with a poster (but only one has the promo sticker on the sleeve telling us this).

Discogs users have strong opinions about the fidelity of the repressing. Whilst the experience isn't exactly, "like the neighbours are playing an Erasure record and you're hearing it through the wall", it definitely has less clarity than the original and the EQ is not sympathetic.

The actual music on this album is very good indeed; but there are a couple of party poopers in here. Things kick off with the mega single "A Little Respect" and another chart success "Ship of Fools" follows hot on its heels. The best track on the album, "Phantom Bride" is criminally tucked away as the third track where it falls in the shadow of "Chains of Love" somewhat. Side one ends with "Hallowed Ground" which is another jewel of a song that stands up against the more up tempo chart singles we have heard to this point.

Unfortunately, the second side of the record is not nearly as strong as the first. Instrumental cover version "Sixty Five Thousand" is fun, but it's pointless pretending it is anything other than filler. "Heart of Stone" is a well executed pop song replete with a typical eighties horn section. However, the sequencing of the album sees the track sit incongruously and it suffers as a result. "Witch in the Ditch" is one of those twee, folk influenced melodies that Erasure seem to generate now and again (see "Crown of Thorns" on follow up "Wild!" as another example) and is probably the low point. 

In my youth I never heard much merit in the final track "Weight of the World". It was only in the last 10 years or so that my wife pointed out it actually is a good song with a strong melody. This forces me to reflect that this track is another victim of poor sequencing. I assumed that this was down to some disinterested intern in A&R, but on conducting a little research I found that it was actually Andy Bell that decided.

It is well documented that the gestation of this album was problematic as Vince found it difficult to work with producer Stephen Hague. I think some of that struggle comes through in the music and tracks like "Imagination" and "Yahoo!" sound like they were thrown down quickly in an effort to get he record finished and draw an end to the whole affair. For the first time on an Erasure album it is easy to identify large numbers of presets and the distinctive EMU Drumulator. The combination of a slightly bland sound palette with poor choices in defining the running order means this album isn't able to achieve the pop perfection that was within reach of Erasure in 1988. 4/5

One record at a time: 114. Erasure - The Two Ring Circus

In the mid eighties any electronic pop album that sold moderately well would almost certainly generate a remix counterpart. Remix albums were the perfect cash cow that could generate large sales at minimal expense, whilst simultaneously extending the longevity of the parent album. I love a good remix album.

Here we have two copies of "The Two Ring Circus" where one is literally a pale imitation of the other. I own an original pressing which is in very good condition, and thanks to the fact that this album is presented as two 45rpm 12" discs, it sounds fantastic. The other copy is a "Queuing for records day" Record Store Day cash-in from 2018. The artwork for the newer version was clearly reproduced from scans as it is rather pale, blurred and not colour matched to the original. This newer version is pressed on yellow vinyl, but as my original copy is in such good condition, I haven't had need to open it.

The remixes on this album aren't radical reinterpretations or even funkier dance versions. No, these mixes belong to the 'tinker with it' school of remixing that was predominant in the eighties. Around 80% of the original backing track always seem to be retained and only the occasional new element added. 

The "Erasure and Flood Remix" of "Sometimes" starts of promisingly but reverts to the same structure as the album version with only the occasional new drum sound thrown in. The most radical mix is probably Louie Vega's version of "Hideaway" which features an extend break and some nice TR-808 hit hats. Daniel Miller's mix of "Don't Dance" is suitably Kraftwerk inspired and is probably the highlight. 

The last three tracks on the album are orchestral interpretations of "If I Could", "Spiralling" and a song from their debut album called "My Heart So Blue". As a fan of electronic music I'm not too interested in these versions and the arrangements sound a little ostentatious for my taste. The live tracks found on the CD (and cassette as I remember) aren't on the vinyl so here we end. 3/5

One record at a time: 113. Erasure - The Circus

The search for a copy of "The Circus" in good condition has resulted in me owning it three times. These records come from a variety of pressing plants and range from good to very good condition. One copy includes a sampler 12" that was bundled by the record company. I'm not clear on why you would include the sampler that duplicates content from the album. Maybe Mute had a warehouse full of them to get rid of.

Vince and Andy's second effort is when things began to take off for the band; and its easy to see why. These tracks have better hooks than "Wonderland" and the production is a big step forwards. Phil Harding provides that PWL sparkle to the mix and almost all of the tracks could have been released as a single. Even the artwork is attractive compared to its predecessor.

The album kicks off with an underrated single "It Doesn't Have To Be" which I considered to epitomise synth pop in my youth. As a teenager I was also slightly obsessed with the melody of "Hideaway" which seemed to weave through the scale like a snake. Unfortunately I didn't give as much attention to the lyrics on some of these songs when I was younger and their message was a little lost on me. The trio of "Don't Dance", "If I Could" and "Sexuality" are all based on strong and empowering messages that I didn't appreciate at the time.

The second half of the album weaves the pop majesty of "Victim of Love" with the plaintive "Leave Me to Bleed" and the undeniable melody of break through hit "Sometimes". The titular single is another underappreciated masterpiece that can instantly transport me back to 1987. "Spiralling" makes for the perfect torch song to round out a great album. 4/5

One record at a time: 112. Erasure - Wonderland

Having worked our way through the Enigma back catalogue, we now face the daunting task of tackling twenty one Erasure albums. We start with thier debut LP, "Wonderland". 

I originally bought a copy of this album in 1987 from a local supermarket (back when supermarkets had record departments) and it came bundled with a 12" of  "Oh l'Amour". However, there was a large gouge in the vinyl and I had to returned it for a refund. A few years later I bought the album on CD and listened to that for the next twenty five years. In 2014 I bought another copy of the vinyl from eBay and this time around the record is in very good condition but no 12" single was included.

They say you should never judge a book by its cover; yet inevitably we do. The same can also be said for records and I know I definitely make judgements about the music based on the artwork presented. I'll cut to the chase and say I hate the artwork for this album and I wish I could divorce it from the music. There's something about the matt brown background and the unfinished images that I dislike intensely.

As for the music, I've said before on this blog that I think this album is a little lacking. "Wonderland" found Vince seemingly devoid of confidence and both the song writing and production are fragile. Whilst the album generally lacks the polish of later efforts, there are some diamonds in the rough.

The two stand out tracks for me are "Push Me, Shove Me" and "Cry So Easy" with everything else falling into the 'OK but nothing special' category. Even the version of "Oh l'Amour" is a little disappointing. I'm feeling generous so I will say this was an adequate first effort but better was to come. 3/5

One record at a time: 111. Enigma - Love Sensuality Devotion (The Greatest Hits)

We round out my Enigma vinyl collection with the 2021 "Monocorm Series" edition of "Love Sensuality Devotion (The Greatest Hits)". This is a 180g vinyl that features material released between 1990 and 2001. As this collection was initially conceived as a compact disc, there are 18 tracks which have to be spread across two vinyl discs.

The obligatory atmospheric introduction is provided by the "The Landing". This track and the single  "Turn Around" were written for this compilation and are competent without being overly impressive.

As "TNT For The Brain" starts I am beginning to notice there is little attention to the band's earlier albums here. The track choices break down as three from the first album, "MCMXC a.D.", four songs each from "The Cross of Changes" and "Le Roi est mort, vive le Roi!" but five from "The Screen Behind the Mirror". We don't get any music from the first and most successful album until we're halfway through the record. 

I find the inclusion of mediocre tracks such as "Morphing Thru Time" and "Smell of Desire" puzzling as they weren't released as singles and I'm not clear on how they became considered 'hits'. I think it would have been better to have culled 4-5 tracks and made this album a more traditional hits package that focussed on their most successful work. Despite some odd track choices this remains a great précis of the bands output from the so called "first chapter".4/5