One record at a time: 346. Orchestral Manoeuvres in the Dark - Souvenir

2019 was the fortieth year of OMD and this is the inevitable singles compilation to mark the anniversary. 

Here we have no less than three slabs of Optimal Media's finest heavyweight vinyl with a cut by Miles Showell at Abbey Road Studios. Yes the packaging is a little lifeless and dull, but the music sounds extraordinary and I have no hesitation in recommending this pressing. Looking back at the invoice I can see I paid a mere £25 for this album. What a bargain. 

The only minor quibble is the fact that the sleeve is rather large and doesn't fit into any conventional protective sleeves - but when that is the worst you can say of a record, you know it must be good.

"Souvenir" is quite comprehensive and features forgotten singles such as "Red Frame/White Light", "Shame" and "Never Turn Away" which are often omitted from lesser compilations. The initiated will appreciate the more exhaustive track listing and the passing fan will still be presented with all the hits they crave. Forty tacks is a lot to swallow in one go, but as the songs are presented chronologically and spread across three discs, this set is easy to dip in and out of. Highly recommended. 4/5

One record at a time: 345. Orchestral Manoeuvres in the Dark - Live With The Royal Liverpool Philharmonic Orchestra

In 2017 OMD released a single called "What Have We Done". If that song had been made available a year later, it wouldn't have been unreasonable to assume it was a reference to this record.

You see "Live With The Royal Liverpool Philharmonic Orchestra" is something of a car crash and is probably the worst thing OMD have ever put out. Not only does this album sound bad, but the route to purchasing it also proved to be tortuous for me.

Back in 2018 I was an avid user of the Pledge Music platform and when this album was launched I decided to back it. What I didn't realise was that Pledge Music had begun experiencing severe financial issues and projects had begun to fall into trouble. 

On the scheduled release day this album was made available digitally with a promise of the vinyl arriving in the near future. However, as time went on it became increasingly apparent that I wasn't going to receive my records. From what I can discern, Pledge Music decided to use everyone's money (including that belonging to some artists) to keep themselves afloat and had stopped fulfilling orders.

Pledge Music was finally put into administration in the summer of 2019 and closed its doors soon after. To be honest, having heard the digital files of this album, I wasn't too worried about the absence of my triple clear vinyl and was resigned to the financial loss. However, during the death throws of the business I think there must some kind of clear out as my order was finally posted six months after it was promised. I was both relieved and crestfallen in equal measure.

OMD seem to be entering into the same cycle that Gary Numan is stuck in where he releases an album, embarks on an extensive tour and then releases at least one (sometimes more) live album before starting the process all over again. I understand that the income model for musicians has changed and that nobody is forcing me to buy these records, but it does besmirch their legacy just a little bit. OMD existed for more than twenty years and ten studio albums without feeling the need to release a live recording. Yet since they reformed in 2006, we have had to endure at least seven of them.

In an attempt to break the monotony of their concerts and live albums, OMD decided to perform for two nights with the The Royal Liverpool Philharmonic Orchestra. The trouble with this idea is that OMD have never really used an orchestra in any of their records and very few of their songs lend themselves to such arrangements. When other artists attempt this sort of thing they tend to use the orchestra to augment the original production and create a more vibrant sound. "Orchesography" by Wang Chung or "Concrete" by Pet Shop Boys are good examples of this approach. 

Unfortunately OMD went in a different direction and decided to rely solely on the orchestral and live vocals. The arrangements are truly tortuous and the orchestra sound out of tune with themselves and the vocalists for the majority of the performance. The finished recording is only slightly above bootleg quality and it doesn't flinch in presenting every rough edge and bum note. Terrible stuff. 1/5

One record at a time: 344. Orchestral Manoeuvres in the Dark - The Punishment of Luxury

Here we have the box set of "The Punishment of Luxury" that featured an exclusive transparent red LP alongside a couple of CDs and a DVD. 

By the time this album came around in 2017 it felt like OMD had settled into a natural cadence of releasing and touring new material every 3-4 years. Since reforming in 2006 the band had also begun to move to an increasingly electronic sound and this record moves us a step further down that road.

If I had to guess I would say that Paul and Andy's favourite Kraftwerk album is "The Man Machine" as this record borrows from every motif, riff and beat on that seminal masterpiece. In fact, you could argue that OMD were carrying the flag for the Düsseldorf electro pioneers at this point as they were the only artists left producing pure electro-pop with commercial appeal.

The title track that opens proceedings is an attack on the vacuous pop culture and social media nonsense some people seem to fill their lives with. The second song "Isotype" is quite different lyrically as it is an ode to the International System of Typographic Picture Education, but both tracks are firmly rooted in the same electronic soil. The magnificent "What Have We Done" is less charged and makes for a nice change of pace, but you can still hear the electronic sensibilities straining to burst out. Honourable mentions must also go to "The View From Here" and the marvellous "One More Time" which are great songs with clear and precise production.

Aside from these highlights there is a series of shorter and largely instrumental tracks that tackle subjects such as art history, machine guns and industrialisation. There's an unexpected expletive amongst the synths of  "Kiss Kiss Bang Bang" and only "Robot Man" stands out for all the wrong reasons.

This is a record of almost unadulterated synth heaven where only the occasional blast of bass guitar is allowed to peek through the digital sheen. Whilst this sleek version of Kraftwerk does sound very good, it is a step away from the traditional sound of OMD. As much as I love the electronic nature of this music, it might have benefited from being dialled back a tiny bit to reveal some of the grit below the surface.  4/5

One record at a time: 343. Orchestral Manoeuvres in the Dark - English Electric

Having re-established themselves with their previous album, OMD upped the ante with "English Electric" in 2013. This is the original 'limited edition' LP that even came with a free CD (it doesn't seem that long ago that this used to happen). The sleeve is a trademark OMD effort with a large die cut window that uses the inner sleeve to compete the image. Unfortunately the designer didn't take the opportunity to put an drawing of an English Electric DP1 prototype train on the front, but you can't have everything.

There's no doubt that this record is a concerted effort to recapture the authentic OMD sound and return them to the electronic music fold. Or as Paul Humphreys described it, "Get rid of all the organic stuff."

The Kraftwerk-esque "Metroland" is simply superb and instantly provides evidence that Paul was more closely involved in the creative process this time around. The Kraftwerk influence continues as they decide to resurrect the Electric Music track "Kissing the Machine" that Andy co-wrote with Karl Bartos some twenty years before. Whilst this version is a good effort, I can't really see why they chose to include it. The fact that there are four new songs included on the CD single of "Night Café" suggests there was more than enough material lying around, so maybe they just liked the song so much they felt compelled to include it.

"Dresden" lays bare the pain Andy faced in his personal life and it sounds like "Stay With Me" was Paul's opportunity to do the same. Both are good songs with strong melodic components and their contrasting styles make for welcome variety. Once again we see a historically important woman used as a metaphor on "Helen of Troy" and "Our System" is yet more Kling-Klang infused goodness.

Another feature of this record is the inclusion of short instrumental pieces. Whilst the tracks themselves are pleasing, I'm not a fan of leaving little bits and pieces dotted around an album. But then OMD have never really been about conforming and following the crowd, so this sort of thing comes with the territory. Whilst I used to think this album was a little light on content, I now see it is actually rather concise and doesn't outstay its welcome. For me, the move to electronic music was most welcome and this is a really good album as a result. 4/5

One record at a time: 342. Orchestral Manoeuvres in the Dark - History of Modern

What better way to celebrate three years of working through my record collection than with an album titled "History of Modern"?

Andy and Paul reformed Orchestral Manoeuvres in the Dark in 2006 and released this album four years later. Originally I bought the box set that included a double LP with a unique sleeve, but more recently I have purchased the 2023 reissue on white vinyl too.

The tracks included here are a mixture of previously discarded material and some new songs of varying merit. Of the older material "Sister Mary Says" is purported to have been composed in 1981 and there is a tacit suggestion it shares some of its DNA with "Enola Gay". The song sounds nothing like its illustrious predecessor and isn't really close to the quality the band used to generate; but it is a fair effort nonetheless. The single "If You Want It" is a leftover from Andy's work with Atomic Kitten and is another well executed if uninspiring song. The only tracks that really don't deserve to be on the record are "Sometimes" and the terrible "Pulse" which drag the overall quality of the record down quite steeply.

My favourite moments are "The Right Side?" and "Green" which sound like they had a much greater input from Paul Humphreys. There's a fantastic love song to four German middle aged men in the form of "RFWK" and the title track has an infectious melody. When I went to see them play on the tour that accompanied this record, it felt like there was a new energy in the air. This record is far from perfect, but it did help solidify relationships in the band and gave sufficient encouragement for them to continue to expand their oeuvre. 3/5

One record at a time: 341. Orchestral Manoeuvres in the Dark - Universal

The original LP of "Universal" from 1996 is a collector's item that can fetch hundreds of pounds. Realistically, the 2021 reissue we have here is the only way the majority of us will be able to listen to this album from vinyl. I purchased a copy of this record as soon as it was made available, but the second one only came into my possession a few weeks ago. 

Whilst looking at the OMD online store I happened to see damaged stock being sold for a mere £5. The record itself was guaranteed to be in perfect condition but it was suggested the sleeve would be disfigured in some way. However, when I opened my parcel I found everything to be in perfect condition. So I now have two.

When I first bought this album on CD I wasn't that impressed by it. By 1996 it seemed the only genre of electronic music anyone was interested in was dance. Having failed with his attempt to dress up his composition for the dance floor on previous album "Liberator", Andy McCluskey decided to go to the dark side. In his own words, "It was important for me to abandon some of the electronic stuff: nobody in the mid‑1990s really wanted '80s synth‑pop any more, which is essentially how OMD were perceived."

In most contemporary articles the word "organic" seems to be used to describe the sound of this record. The aim seemed to be to create something akin to the sound of Pulp and Andy even went as far as hiring their engineering team to produce the record. The fact that some of the songs on this record were written alongside former Kraftwerk member Karl Bartos gives you some idea of just how deep the poison of Britpop sank into nineties music (Bartos himself would go on to create his own 'guitar pop' album a couple of years later, but I'm sure we will come back to that abomination eventually.)

The title track has a two minute long intro that suggests experimentation was not entirely dead, but the Korg M1 "Universe" preset really should have been put out to pasture years ago. As the song progresses we can hear guitars, bass and drums alongside dominant backing singers. A good song, but OMD this is not. Similarly the other single taken from the album, "Walking on the Milky Way" has a strong melody but its jangling guitars and repetitive nature detract from the overall effect.

Not content with borrowing from Britpop alone, McCluskey appropriates other genres from the nineties with the psychedelic rock of Primal Scream on "New Head" and the Asian influenced sounds of Kula Shaker imitated on "Very Close to Far Away". "Gospel of St Jude" is a noble effort, but such music doesn't suit an OMD record at all. This album seems to move through many styles, but none really fit.

On the plus side "Moon & the Sun" is a magnificent song and "That Was Then" has a tension that builds to a magical conclusion. "The Boy from the Chemist is here to see you" is close to the traditional sound of OMD and the use of Korg M1 piano on "Victory Waltz" may be lazy, but it does at least bring back memories of "Sugar Tax". 

Unfortunately this album was not a commercial success and a disillusioned Andy McCluskey decided to draw the curtains on OMD in 1996. Whilst I was sad at the demise of the band I understood why it needed to happen and there was plenty of new music to fill the void for me back in the nineties. I want to give this album a higher score, but without rose tinted spectacles or the ephemeral joy of receiving a copy for £5 I am forced to go low. 2/5

One record at a time: 340. Orchestral Manoeuvres in the Dark - Liberator

A few weeks ago I was idly flicking through eBay when I noticed a listing for the original pressing of "Liberator" priced at £12.99. "That's a fair price for a record that is getting scarcer," I thought. It was only as my eyes focused that I realised the price was actually £129.99. 

On further inspection I saw another copy for the slightly lower price of £109.99 and a signed copy at an eye watering £199.99. Admittedly these records don't seem to be selling, but the mean price on Discogs where they do sell is still around £30.

I find these prices staggering as I bought my copy ten years ago for the princely sum of £7 - and that was overpriced. I can only assume that all of the original copies have now been squirrelled away in people's record collections and demand has exceeded supply. Even a reissue in 2021 doesn't seem to have dented demand for the original. I guess this is just a sign of how the popularity of vinyl has increased in recent years.

The demand for this vinyl is quite puzzling as the album has been largely dismissed by Andy McCluskey as "messed up" and it doesn't seem to win many plaudits from fans either. Personally, I recall hearing the lead single "Stand Above Me" being played on the radio prior to the album's release and I was impressed enough to buy the CD single. This track is clearly an attempt to repeat the formula used by the hit "Sailing on the Seven Seas" but it falls well short of that high watermark. 

If we're honest we would have to say that most of the material on this album is pretty middling with few highs to be found. "Everyday", "Dollar Girl" and "Heaven Is" are all fairly good compositions but their execution is a bit confused. I'm not sure what possessed Andy to record a cover version of a Velvet Underground song and the faux rave of "Agnus Dei" is best forgotten. Yet, I like this album very much as it reminds me of the summer of 1993 and some good times in my life. Objectively this isn't one of the band's best, but it is special to me. Still not worth £130 though. 4/5