This album is another ponderous beast that explores the musical wilderness between art-rock and prog-rock. My copy is a 2015 remastered version split across 2 LPs.
Opening tracks "All Sweet Things" and "Beautiful Songs You Should Know" are kitchen sink dramas played out on acoustic guitar, piano and Tim's distinctive vocal tones. These song neither offend nor ignite the imagination.
"Pigeon Drummer" begins as a slow and quiet instrumental before suddenly exploding into a sea of tom drums and squealing guitars. This might have seemed like a neat trick when it was conceived but it only serves to destroy the mood for me.
There's some wonderful strings on the first part of "Truenorth" which eventually combine with a welcome hip hop beat. As Tim sings of surrendering to the night and the orchestra swells, you realise this is one of the best songs No-Man have recorded in many years. Yes, it is overly long at twelve minutes (maybe they could have chopped out one or two of the jazz flute solos), but it will reward those who persevere.
"Wherever There Is Light" lost my interest the second a pedal steel guitar began howling but "Song of the Surf" is much more interesting and has a great melody. There's another trace of a beat on "Streaming" but the pedal steel guitar comes in to ruin any promise the composition might have shown. The final track "Mixtaped" is far too self indulgent and, whilst the band might have had great fun recording it, it's not much fun to listen to. There are three bonus tracks on side four but none of them stand out particularly. All the marks for this album go to the majestic "Truenorth", everything else is fairly superfluous. 2/5
